A little story about the Melvins, Mr. Bungle and me

So I’ve just finished up a couple of interviews with Buzz Osbourne and Dale Crover of the Melvins, one of the greatest bands of time and space — more about that piece when it runs! Both very personable guys and while I’ve no doubt I was just one of a million interviewers they talked to this week they had some good thoughts and great quotes.

They also remembered one of the most amazing shows I’ve ever seen, ever. Good friend Mackro saw it too; he and I were a few months away from meeting for the first time but I had gone down to OC with my friend Steve to see the show and he likewise had come up from UCI with friend Dave to see it.

What follows, originally typed up some years ago (and with a lot of tics and quirks that frankly I cringe to see now), is my story, modified by Mackro’s memories, as well as what Buzz and Dale confirmed just now, plus the prompt of a recording of the show I got from a hyperBungle fan a few years back (much of the detail of the show I’d remembered perfectly, though not all of it). Enjoy:

Down in the sweet balm of Orange County, at the long-gone and unlamented Celebrity Theatre in Anaheim, a ye olde theatre-in-the-round, Mr. Bungle announces a show, to considerable excitement in certain sectors. The lingering KNAC crowd is especially drawn to this, due to the Faith No More connection, which is about all most people have actually heard (those wondering about KNAC need know only this, that it was a station which nowadays in its online only format pretends it was all Metallica back in 1987 when in fact Ratt and Poison and so forth were its bread and butter more so than our favorite Napster-lovin’ combo — but I digress). In the meantime, feckless young innocents as myself and Mackro, though we did not know each other at the time, who actually had heard the album and loved it, considered this a Distinct Blessing, as FNM were about to fire up the Angel Dust tour and Bungle would have to disappear for a while. Off we all went.

As friend Steve and I fended our way past the leathery-faced 35-and-up permatan David Coverdale rock dude and dudette types, as well as the more understandable young semi-proto grunge/whatever crowd, we concluded that this was perhaps going to be a strange evening. (MACKRO — don’t forget the Red Hot Chili Peppers/Fishbone dorks..) Grotus was the opening band, so we settled on in as they Did Their Thing, and it was a fairly fine thing at that, industrial rock hoohah of a gone sort. Viva, etc., off they go, the Young Gods’ TV Sky plays on the monitors, and the next band sets up.

Said band are them glorious Melvins, who do their thing — which is not what the crowd came to hear. As time passes, said crowd turns ugly, as cheerful cries of “You suck!” increase in volume. The Melvins mostly laugh their asses off and keep doing what they do, finally leaving to the general crowd’s delight. (MACKRO — Joe Preston didn’t seem to care, Buzzo tried to make the songs slower and more grueling, AND AND AND Dale Crover went up to the mike after their set and said to the crowd “Mr. Bungle says fuck you”) Myself, I was new to them and didn’t know entirely what to think, but I thought most folks were being way too harsh.

As it happened, Bungle very clearly agreed with me.

[2008 EDIT — Mackro and I had heard a couple of stories about this but here’s the full skinny: as Buzz and Dale confirmed to me, Mike Patton saw how the Melvins were treated, immediately tore up the setlist for Mr. Bungle and wrote out a new one directed at the audience which read “TONIGHT THEY WILL PAY.”]

Bungle take the stage, dressed entirely in combinations of wrestling masks, Aztec outfits and other oddities — no surprise there, per se. The crowd is cheering, pumped, the pit is ready, bring it on. The band acknowledge no-one and nothing, finish setting up and launch into…

…a twenty-minute low-key jazz noodle (MACKRO — eeh wouldn’t say that… it was more of a Melvins/Earth type guitar buzz except even more minimal and grueling/MY 2008 EDIT: Mackro’s right, as the recording confirmed.). Patton wanders around the stage, apparently speaking in tongues to himself. The band then play the closest thing to a cover version of Spinal Tap’s “Jazz Odyssey” there is, only without the energy and pace. It’s…interesting, true. The crowd vaguely quiets down, then starts to get more and more impatient. Bungle, of course, ignore their feelings entirely. It gets to the point where the pit starts crowd-surfing even when there is *no* music remotely approaching pit/mosh/surf levels, which apparently increases the band’s utter contempt for the crowd. (2008 EDIT: both Buzz and Dale remembered that as well!)

After that, for the next thirty minutes or so, Bungle proceed to play one of the most fucked-up sets I’ve heard in a while. Ignoring their album entirely, they proceed to amuse themselves with some indescribable nonsense, interspersed with equally indescribable cover versions. Thus, we are entertained at points by a cover of Tom Jones’ Bond theme “Thunderball,” sung by Patton in a strangled roar (2008 EDIT: Dale remembers that there were a bunch of older ladies in the audience, which is where he must have been watching the show and laughing at the festivities; he had no idea why they were there — ‘must have been somebody’s moms or something’ — but that when “Thunderball” started they all got excited and went “Tom Jones!”), and that one Alan Parsons Project song that goes, “Time…keeps flowing like a river…to the sea…,” except Bungle turned up the amps and Patton practically yells out, “TIME…KEEPS FLOWING LIKE A RIVERRRRR…TO *THE SEA!!!*”… (MACKRO — they also did a song without any instruments, just this Negativland-ish sample loopy thing.)

Somewhere in all this, while starting at last to do songs from the first record, the drummer busts out the Queen “We Will Rock You” beat or its equivalent and Patton gets the crowd going with claps and shouts, leading to this priceless exchange:

Patton: “All right everyone, REPEAT AFTER ME! (in time to the beat) BUD-WEI-SER!”
Crowd: “BUD-WEI-SER!”
Patton: “MICH-EL-OB!”
Crowd: “MICH-EL-OB!”

This goes on, other music and songs are performed. Then all of a sudden there’s a pause:

Patton: “All right, now! I LOVE THE MEL-VINS!”
Crowd: “I LOVE The mel…” (fading rapidly as they realize what they’re saying)
Patton: *bending back, in full madman voice* “AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAAA!” *turns away and ignores crowd*

They end up doing a few first album songs, but only that — “Travolta,” “Love is a Fist,” “My Ass is On Fire.” They abandon the stage. To my semi-surprise, there’s enough cheering and callbacks for an encore, as many others have been booing lustily and complaining loudly. So the band come back for an encore…logically, it’s another weird-ass crazy jam of something nobody recognizes.

And then this happens:

As one, the rest of the band stop what they’re doing and turn to the drummer. Initially he looks confused, as far as anyone can tell with his mask on. The others then start singing, enjoyably, “Happy birthday to you! Happy birthday to…” etc.

The drummer stands up, a look of fear showing through his mask. He immediately throws his sticks down and runs off. Remember that this is a theatre in the round, with the band set up center, playing to one half of the venue, the other half roped off and empty. So the drummer charges up one of the empty aisles as fast as he can.

The other band members are displeased with this. They therefore drop *their* instruments and charge after him. To Steve’s and my utter amazement, we see them catch up with the drummer and, as best as we can tell, completely beat the living shit out of him!

And that was it. No ‘good night,’ no final announcement, nothing. Shortly thereafter the lights go up, so we all leave.

Steve and I were utterly, totally amazed, we had clearly seen one of the best shows of our lives, something Brian agreed with me on when we compared notes much later. All around us the leathery types and moshpit morons and others were bitching and complaining and saying what shit it was — we realized that they had completely and utterly missed the joke on them. It was conceptual art terrorism of a high degree, and I’ve never seen anything like it since.

(2008 EDIT — I just realized I forgot to ask Buzz and Dale to fully confirm that last part. If it was only a fever dream of an ending, well, it only seemed appropriate.)

23 Responses to “A little story about the Melvins, Mr. Bungle and me”

  1. StanM Says:

    AWESOME!!! I love the Melvins & Patton & co even more now! Thanks for that!

  2. chaki Says:

    wait so was it danny heifitz they beat up??

  3. Ned Raggett Says:

    If he was drumming at the time! And see, this is why I wished I’d asked Dale/Buzz more about that because maybe I had the whole damn thing wrong, but that’s what I remember about the end!

  4. mrg Says:

    that’s glorious. thank you, mr raggett. thank you.

  5. Ned Raggett Says:

    Too kind of you.

  6. Gezarie Says:

    Man this story made my day! That sounds like a crazy amazing gig, i wish i coulda been there. Though i’d have been a toddler so possibly not a good idea.
    FUCK i love Mr Bungle, cheers for this man. Nicely written i might add, i could clearly see it all playing out in front of me. Can’t wait to read ur Buzz and Dale interview =o)

  7. Ned Raggett Says:

    Hey, thanks man. đŸ™‚ Yeah, the interview turned out well, hope everyone likes the story!

    The recording of this Bungle show is out there but it just can’t capture the awkward brilliance of seeing it all happen. If only there was a video of it!

  8. cottonballs Says:

    yep that sure sounds like bungle. awesome stuff, thanks for the story.

    I was at a bungle show in SF back in 93-94 and someone threw a boot and hit patton in the head. he unzips his jumpsuit and pees into the boot. then he drank it. i heard he needed stitching on his noggin after the show. the moment i remember most is the collective gasp and awe (and silence) as he gulped down urine from the boot.

    anyone else at that show?


    • LoveIsAFist Says:

      I was there! That was new years 92/93 SF @ the Bill Graham Auditorium. Melvins and Mr. Bungle opened up for Primus that evening. Patton was wearing an S&M mask. I recall Patton peeing in the boot then and dumped it on his face.

  9. And from a few days back — my first Quietus review « Ned Raggett Ponders It All Says:

    […] on one point. Hopefully my response comment, when posted, clarifies things. (If it doesn’t, just read this story — as, for whatever reason, a whole slew of people have been doing lately — and laugh […]

  10. ijwthstd Says:

    I was at that show! I don’t remember them beating up the drummer but I remember them just leaving after “Happy Birthday Dear…” they all put down their instruments and bailed. 2 nights later in Ventura with just Grotus opening and 50-100 in attendance was a bit more like the usual Bungle shows of the era.

  11. Ned Raggett Says:

    If the thing about the drummer was just a crazy fever dream on our parts then no worries but I could swear that’s what we saw. Anyway, good to meet a fellow vet.

  12. Da Thirst Says:

    Never saw Mr. Bungle, but saw Melvins at least 10 times. First time they were opening (with Surgery) for GWAR. They played the slowest, droning stuff that went on for 20 minutes…sounded like an extended version of “Eye Flys” or “Boris” or something…the college jocks in the crowd get mad “play faster! Fuck you! etc.”

    Joe responded by slowly yet menacingly swinging the mic stand out toward the crowd, looking at the offenders with a malevolent glare. He then cheerfully went on the mic and announced, “Y’all gotta be the biggest bunch of faggots ah ever seen in mah life!” shortly before they left the stage.

    Since then they’ve been one of my favorites, and I’ve never had to see them antagonize a crowd because the crowds came to see THE MELVINS, not GWAR.

  13. The Dude Says:

    Buzz had a problem with his amp during the Melvins set… so there was an extended break while he was trying to fix it. Several people in the crowd yelled encouragingly for the long haired bearded bass player (Joe Preston?) to break the silence by saying “PLAY SOMETHING JESUS!!” Memorable night to be sure… including the bizarre Happy Birthday sudden ending.

    • Ned Raggett Says:

      Hahaha I had forgotten that detail from the Melvins set but it sounds perfectly appropriate given Joe’s look. Be great if he went away and changed into robes or something.

  14. Johnny T Says:

    I was at that show. After the Melvin’s set, we ran into Mr. Bungle’s guitarist who said they were going to start a riot because they were pissed at how the crowd was treating the Melvins. I remember the first 30 mins of noise and Patton swinging the mic by the cord.

    One cover they played that made my day was a D.R.I. song from Dealing With It.

  15. Bob Says:

    Sounds like a pretty awful gig. But ‘art terrorism’ smdh.

  16. Hans Says:

    The Melvins opened up with that first track on “Lysol” – which is basically Buzz droning on for 10 minutes with an occasional crash from Dale and Joe…. as Buzz was droning on and the crowd getting angry (not getting the brilliance in front of them), Buzz’s amp breaks down, the crowd loves it cuz they hates the Melvins, the heckling was savage…. some one yelled “Bass solo” and Joe did a rudimentary 2 note trill, the crowd loved it: sarcastically….. finally, Buzz gets his amp fixed, and he goes right back into his 3 note drone for another 10 minutes, AMAZING… the crowd gets more angry, until the Melvins actually start playing “music”… the crowd swayed along with the 60 bmp tempo, hating the sound, but happy it wasn’t silence… at the time, I didn’t get what the Melvins were doing, until I borrowed their Lysol cassette… I was hooked…..
    I don’t recall Patton sticking anything up his ass….different show I believe, cuz us L.A. folks heard the rumors about that incident happening at a different show.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: